Picky eater or feeding problem? Signs it’s time for a feeding evaluation

Is picky eating normal, and when should I worry?

Picky eating is common in toddlers. For weeks at a time, a toddler may eat one or two favorite foods and nothing else. It’s time to ask about a feeding evaluation when your child eats fewer than about 20 foods, cries or falls apart when a new food appears, refuses whole groups of foods or textures, or isn’t gaining weight. Those are some of the signs that set a problem feeder apart from a picky eater.

At a glance

  • Who it’s for: babies, toddlers and children whose eating worries you.
  • Which therapy: feeding therapy.
  • Where: all three of our offices: Smyrna/Vinings, Atlanta (North Druid Hills) and Marietta.
  • Insurance: In network with Aetna, Cigna (speech therapy), Curative and Kaiser Permanente, and with Anthem/Blue Cross Blue Shield and Georgia Medicaid plans (see every plan). At our practice, Cigna is in network for speech therapy only; benefits vary by plan. We can help you understand your benefits.
  • How to start: call us at 770-927-7424, or press Start Your Journey and fill out our quick form.

Picky eater or problem feeder? Signs to look for

These comparisons can help you see whether your child’s eating looks like a passing phase or something more.

How picky eaters and problem feeders differ. The SOS Approach to Feeding compares them like this:

  • How many foods: picky eaters usually eat at least 30 different foods. Problem feeders usually eat fewer than 20.
  • Foods that drop off: when a picky eater tires of a food, they will normally eat it again after a two-week break. A problem feeder rarely accepts that food again.
  • New foods: a picky eater can usually touch or taste a new food. A problem feeder may cry, protest and fall apart when one is offered.
  • Whole groups of foods: a picky eater eats at least one food from most textures and food groups. A problem feeder refuses entire categories.
  • Family meals: a picky eater usually eats with the family, even if the foods are different. A problem feeder often doesn’t eat with the family.
  • How long: picky eating that has lasted less than two years looks more like a phase; more than two years points toward a feeding problem.

When it’s more than picky eating. Signs that your child may have a pediatric feeding disorder include:

  • Extreme food selectivity based on texture, color and taste
  • Food refusal with gagging, vomiting, hitting or crying
  • Limited appetite
  • Poor weight gain, or not gaining weight
  • Delayed eating skills
  • Disruptive mealtime behavior
  • Eating differently in different places
  • Eating that takes a toll on family life

Signs in how your child eats. Watch for eating only certain textures, taking a long time to eat, holding food in the mouth (“pocketing”), problems chewing, and coughing or gagging during meals.

What to expect by age 2 to 3. Most children this age chew all foods, even tougher textures, without gagging or choking. They drink from an open cup and feed themselves with a fork and spoon, though they often still use their fingers.

If you’re curious how chewing and drinking skills build over time, our blog covers the stages of oral motor development and why we like straw cups better than sippy cups.

When to call your pediatrician, and who else can help

Call your pediatrician first if your child is losing weight or seems unwell. If your child coughs or chokes when eating, refuses food or drink, has a wet, gurgly voice after eating, starts to lose weight or has less energy than usual, talk to your doctor about seeing a feeding and swallowing professional.

For everyday worries about what your child eats, your pediatrician can help troubleshoot and make sure your child is getting the nutrients they need to grow and develop. If the problem-feeder signs sound familiar, ask your pediatrician about feeding therapy.

If your child is under 3:

  • Feeding Matters offers a free online Infant and Child Feeding Questionnaire for children up through 36 months. It corrects for prematurity and gives you a way to discuss your concerns with your child’s doctor.
  • Georgia’s early intervention program, Babies Can’t Wait, serves children from birth to their third birthday. You don’t have to wait for a doctor’s referral or a diagnosis to contact them.

You’re also welcome to call us with your questions at any point.

How feeding therapy at Talk About Therapy helps

The evaluation. We start with an in-depth evaluation that looks at the reasons behind your child’s eating, not just the foods on the plate. Gagging or a short list of safe foods can have different causes, and the evaluation helps us understand your child’s.

Goals you set with us. We sit down with you to talk about what you hope to see at mealtimes, and we build your child’s goals together. Feeding therapy is tailored to your child’s needs.

What sessions look like. Feeding therapy usually takes place around a meal or snack. We work with you directly at the table, so you’re learning the techniques as we use them. When a child needs oral-motor work for chewing and moving food in the mouth, we use oral-motor techniques too.

Your part at home. You’re with your child at most meals, so we help you use the techniques and strategies at home.

Sensory-related eating and autism. Some children avoid foods because of how they feel, smell or look. We’re trained to provide feeding therapy for sensory-related difficulties, including for autistic children. You can read more on our autism page.

What we don’t do. You may read about ARFID (avoidant/restrictive food intake disorder) online; that’s a diagnosis we don’t make, so if it’s on your mind, raise it with your pediatrician.

Often seen together

If eating was hard from the start, with bottle or breastfeeding trouble, read trouble with bottle or breastfeeding.

Questions parents ask

Will my child grow out of picky eating?

For many toddlers, picky eating is just a normal stage. No one can predict it for your child from a list, though. If the problem-feeder signs above sound familiar, or picky eating has lasted more than two years, it’s worth an evaluation rather than more waiting.

Should I keep offering new foods?

Yes, gently. It can take 10 or more tastes before a toddler accepts a new food. If new foods bring gagging, vomiting or a meltdown every time, tell your pediatrician and consider a feeding evaluation.

My child eats well at daycare but not at home. Does that mean anything?

It can. Eating differently in different places is one sign that picky eating may be more than a phase. Note what your child eats in each place and bring that list to the evaluation.

Does insurance cover feeding therapy?

It depends on your plan. We’re in network with Aetna, Curative, Kaiser Permanente, Anthem/Blue Cross Blue Shield and Georgia Medicaid plans, and with Cigna for speech therapy only. Private pay options are available. We can help you understand your benefits.


How to Start

To start, press Start Your Journey just below and fill out our quick form, or call 770-927-7424. We’ll call you back to book the evaluation.

Hablamos español.

Sources